- 1923 – 1935 Peter Longlow
- 1936 – 1942 William Williams
- 1943 – 1950 George Brundage
- 1951 – 1953 Harry Sauer Sr.
- 1954 – 1956 William Gauquie Sr.
- 1957 – 1959 George Brundage
- 1960 – 1961 Harry Sauer Sr.
- 1961 – 1962 James Grant
- 1962 – 1964 George Brundage
- 1965 – 1966 Robert Dawson
- 1967 – 1968 Fred Staples
- 1968 – 1969 John Lathrop
- 1970 – 1971 Michael Fasano
- 1972 – 1973 Richard Yorke
- 1974 – 1975 William Wright
- 1976 – 1977 Harry J. Sauer
- 1978 – 1979 Michael Schiraldi Sr.
- 1980 – 1985 Bernard Collins
- 1986 – 1995 Michael Schiraldi Sr.
- 1996 – 1997 Martin Kroemer
- 1998 – 2001 William Caven Jr.
- 2002 – 2003 Joseph Palazzolo
- 2004 – 2006 Michael Schiraldi, Jr.
- 2007 – 2008 Paul Wall
- 2009 – 2012 Michael Schiraldi, Jr.
- 2013-Present Vinny Araneo