- 1923 – 1924 John D. Garrison
- 1925 – 1928 Egbert Seaman
- 1929 – 1936 Theodore Clark
- 1937 – 1950 George Brundage
- 1951 – 1952 Michael Keller
- 1953 – 1954 Henry Rolufs
- 1955 – 1956 Walter Seaman
- 1956 – 1957 Hugh DeRobertis Sr.
- 1957 – 1959 William Gauquie Sr.
- 1960 – 1964 Walter Seaman
- 1965 – 1972 William Caven Sr.
- 1973 – 1974 Fred Goodrich
- 1975 – 1976 Harry Sauer Sr.
- 1976 – 1977 Fred Goodrich
- 1978 – 1982 George Knights
- 1983 – 1985 Paul Goodrich
- 1985 – 1987 Rick Lewis
- 1988 – 1989 Michael Schiraldi Jr.
- 1990 – 1992 Martin Kroemer
- 1993 – 1994 James E. McCann